Laminate vs. Hardwood Refinishing: What Each Costs and Which Fits

Laminate cannot be refinished. Hardwood can, again and again. That one fact drives most of the decision. If you already own hardwood that looks tired, refinishing is almost always the cheaper path than tearing it out, and it keeps a floor that can last for generations. If you are choosing between two new floors, the comparison is about more than the sticker price.
This guide covers what each option costs per square foot, what “refinish” actually means, why laminate is replaced rather than renewed, and how to tell whether your hardwood is a good candidate. It is written for homeowners in the St. Louis metro and central Illinois who are weighing a new floor against the one underfoot.
TL;DR
Laminate can’t be sanded or refinished. When it wears out or a plank is damaged, planks get replaced.
Hardwood refinishing typically runs $3 to $8 per square foot, and replacing hardwood can cost well over three times as much as refinishing it.
Most hardwood with enough wood above the nails or tongue can be sanded and refinished. Cupped floors and thin wear layers need a closer look first.
Not every dull floor needs a full sand. A screen and recoat or a clean and buff may be all it takes.
We offer in-home consultations so you can see what your floor needs before you decide to replace it.
Table of Contents
What “refinishing” means, and why laminate can’t do it
The National Wood Flooring Association (NWFA) defines refinishing as sanding a previously finished floor down to bare wood and applying new stain or finish. That process only works on a floor that is wood all the way through its top layer, because you are literally removing a thin skin of it.
Laminate is built differently. Its surface is a printed image of wood grain protected by a hard coating, sitting on a fiberboard core. There is no real wood on top to sand. A major laminate manufacturer states in its U.S. support documentation that laminate flooring cannot be sanded. Damaged boards can be replaced or touched up with a repair filler, but the floor cannot be renewed as a whole.
So the answer to “can you refinish laminate?” is no. What you can do is repair a spot or swap out planks. When the surface wears through across a room, the room gets a new floor.
What each option costs
Prices vary by region, wood species, the condition of the floor and how much furniture has to move. Published national ranges give you a starting frame:
Option | Typical cost per sq ft | Source |
Refinishing existing hardwood | $3 to $8 | |
New laminate, installed | $1 to $6 | |
New hardwood, installed | $6 to $12 |
On a 2,000-square-foot home, the simple arithmetic on those ranges looks like this:
Refinishing all the hardwood: roughly $6,000 to $16,000.
Installing new laminate throughout: roughly $2,000 to $12,000.
Installing new hardwood throughout: roughly $12,000 to $24,000.
Those totals are multiplication of the published ranges, not quotes. Your actual number depends on what your floor needs, and that is why a look at the floor in person beats any calculator.
Refinishing versus replacing hardwood
If the real contest is “refinish what I have” against “rip it out,” refinishing wins on cost. NerdWallet notes that it is almost always cheaper to refinish than to replace hardwood, since replacement adds materials, labor and demolition, and depending on the wood you could spend over three times as much. We go deeper on that in why refinishing beats floor replacement cost.
Refinishing versus switching to laminate
Laminate can come in lower per square foot on paper, especially at the budget end. But the comparison is not like for like. Refinishing is a service performed on a floor you already own, and the result is real wood with a new finish. Laminate means removing the existing floor, buying new material and installing it. You are also trading a floor that can be renewed for one that eventually has to be replaced.
If you are sorting through the new-floor side of this, our laminate vs hardwood guide covers cost, durability and which to choose.
Lifespan and repairs
According to Forbes Home, laminate averages 15 to 25 years when well maintained, while hardwood can last up to 100 years with proper care. The same article points out the repair difference: damaged hardwood can be sanded down and refinished, while damaged laminate boards must be removed and replaced.

That difference shows up in ordinary life. A dog scratches the floor near the back door. A chair leg digs a groove. A water glass leaves a ring. On hardwood, these are surface problems in a material that can be sanded and refinished. NWFA’s homeowner guidance says solid wood can be sanded and refinished many times, while engineered wood usually can be refinished too, though not always as many times.
If you want the long view, see why hardwood outlasts other flooring types.
Resale value
NerdWallet cites the National Association of Realtors’ 2022 Remodeling Impact Report, which found that refinishing hardwood floors recovered more of its cost than every other interior project measured. The average homeowner spent $3,400 and gained $5,000 in value, a 147% recovery. Your return will depend on the starting condition of the floors and what you spend, but the pattern is clear: renewing existing hardwood tends to pay back.
We break down the numbers in hardwood floor refinishing investment benefits.
Does your hardwood qualify for refinishing?
Most hardwood does. A few conditions deserve a careful look before anyone runs a sander.
Wear layer thickness
Sanding removes wood, so there has to be enough left. For previously finished floors, NWFA guidelines say floors with a wear thickness below 3/32 inch generally should not be sanded. The association’s Refinishable Program sets minimums of 2.5 mm (3/32 inch) for factory-finished smooth flooring and 3.2 mm (4/32 inch) for unfinished smooth flooring. This mostly matters for engineered floors with a thin top layer. Site-finished solid hardwood usually has plenty to work with.
How many times a floor can be sanded depends on several things, according to the National Wood Flooring Association: contractor skill, equipment, wear-layer thickness, flatness and the floor’s condition. That is one reason who does the sanding matters as much as the floor itself.
Moisture and cupping
If boards are cupped, with edges higher than centers, the cause is nearly always moisture. Industry guidance says a cupped floor should not be repaired until the moisture source is eliminated and the floor has reached equilibrium with normal in-use conditions. If moisture has weakened the fasteners or adhesive, affected boards or subfloor may need replacement, re-fastening or approved adhesive injection.

This is a timing issue, not a verdict. Sanding too early can leave a floor that flattens and then re-cups. Our guide on cupped hardwood repair explains why waiting a few weeks matters.
To keep boards stable year-round, NWFA recommends holding the home between 60 and 80°F and 30 to 50% humidity. That matters in the Midwest, where humid summers and dry, heated winters swing hard.
Damage that needs a full sand
A complete sand and refinish is the right call for deep scratches, dents, other damage, or a finish worn away to bare wood, per NWFA. Floors that are only dull may need far less.
Match the service to the floor
Refinishing is not one job. The right service depends on how the floor looks and feels.
Floor condition | What usually fits | Our service |
Dull, lightly worn, finish intact | Clean the surface and restore the sheen | |
Dull with fine scratches, finish still sound | Lightly abrade and add a fresh coat | |
Old wax buildup, hazy or sticky surface | Strip the wax before any new finish | |
Deep scratches, worn-through finish, color change wanted | Sand to bare wood, stain and refinish |
NWFA notes that when floors look dull, a maintenance coat may be the solution: clean the existing finish, lightly sand it and apply a fresh coat of finish. Many homeowners who are ready to replace a floor because it looks tired find a lighter service is enough. Which one fits is something you can usually tell by looking at the floor in person.
When laminate makes sense, and when hardwood wins
If you are building out a space that has no hardwood, such as a basement, laminate is a legitimate product with a scratch-resistant surface, a lower typical price and quick installation. The conversation changes when hardwood is already in the room.
If your home has hardwood now, think about it this way:
You keep a floor that can be renewed. Each refinish resets the surface.
You avoid demolition and disposal. Removing a floor adds cost and mess before the new one even goes down.
You keep the character. Real wood in an older home is part of what buyers look for.
You can change the look. A full sand allows a new stain color on the same boards.
If you are comparing other alternatives, we have also written on LVP versus hardwood, engineered versus solid hardwood and cork versus hardwood.
Our perspective
We have been restoring floors across central Illinois and the St. Louis metro since 2003, and the same moment comes up again and again. A homeowner calls because the floors look beat up and they are ready to replace them, often with laminate. Then we walk the house and find real wood under the wear. That is why our tagline is “Before you REFLOOR it, let us RESTORE it.” Hardwood is the one floor you can start over on. Laminate has no second chance on the surface, so when it wears out, the whole floor goes. We also know that a messy, week-long project is what stops people from refinishing. So we use dustless techniques and eco-friendly products on every job. Most restoration services are completed in a single day, and floors are ready to walk on in about three hours. Our advice is simple: find out what your floor actually needs before you decide it needs replacing. Often the answer is lighter than you expect. Kim
See what your floor needs before you replace it
We serve homeowners in St. Louis, Monroe and Madison Counties, including Columbia, Belleville, Fairview Heights, Waterloo, O’Fallon, Edwardsville, Glen Carbon, Clayton, Chesterfield and surrounding communities. An in-home consultation is the quickest way to learn whether your floor needs a clean and buff, a screen and recoat, or a full sand and refinish, and what each would involve in your home.

Book an in-home consultation and we will look at your floors with you. If you already know you want a full renewal, start with our sand, stain and refinishing service. Refinishing also pairs well with kitchen updates, and we clean, polish and seal stone surfaces too: see our countertop services.
Wondering about doing it yourself? We compare the two routes in professional floor refinishing vs DIY.
A quick way to decide
Work through these in order:
Is the floor real hardwood or engineered wood? If yes, refinishing is on the table. If it is laminate, replacement is the only way to renew it.
Is the finish dull or is the wood damaged? Dull finish often means a lighter service. Deep gouges and bare wood point to a full sand.
Any signs of moisture? Cupping, soft spots or staining mean the source comes first, then the floor.
Is there enough wood left? Thin engineered wear layers need an expert opinion.
Is there wax or an old buildup? That needs to come off before anything new goes on.
If you answer “hardwood” to the first question, you probably have more options than you think.
FAQ
Can you refinish laminate flooring?
No. Laminate has a printed surface over a fiberboard core, so there is no real wood layer to sand, and manufacturers say it cannot be sanded. Damaged planks can be replaced or filled and touched up. When the surface wears out across a room, the floor is replaced.
Is it cheaper to refinish hardwood or install laminate?
By the national ranges, refinishing typically runs $3 to $8 per square foot and installed laminate $1 to $6, so laminate can cost less up front. Refinishing renews a floor you already have and keeps real wood, while laminate adds removal and a new floor that has a shorter typical lifespan. The best way to compare is to get a refinishing assessment for your actual floor.
How much does it cost to refinish 2,000 square feet of hardwood?
Applying the typical $3 to $8 per square foot range gives roughly $6,000 to $16,000. Where you land depends on the condition of the floor, the species, the number of coats and whether you want a color change. A light service such as a screen and recoat is a different job from a full sand.
When should you not refinish hardwood floors?
Hold off if boards are cupped from active moisture, because the source should be fixed and the floor allowed to stabilize first. Floors with wear layers under 3/32 inch generally should not be sanded either. A professional can measure the wood and tell you which situation you have.
Sources
Recommended





Comments